Review na fim "Elegy"

Sunan : Elegy
Nau'in : karin bayani, wasan kwaikwayo
Darakta : Isabel Kuakse
Shekara : 2008
Ƙasar : Amurka
Budget : $ 13,000,000
Duration : minti 108.

Labarin dangantakar da ke tsakanin David Kepes (Ben Kingsley) - malamin kolejin da kuma matasan Sanalan Consuelo Costilo (Penelope Cruz) wanda ya hadu a Birnin New York. Shi dan wasa ne kawai wanda ya dauki ma'anar juyin juya halin jima'i, ya bar matarsa ​​da 'ya'yansa don dawowa da jima'i. Ita ce kawai 'yar' yar Katolika na 'yan asalin Hispanic. Kuma gulf gulf a tsakanin su zama ƙasa don wani mummunan labari, wanda ya jefa Kepesh daga m wani abu da ba shi da kyau dangantaka a cikin guguwa na ƙauna da kishi ...


A shekara ta 2001, Philippe Roth da aka girmama da kuma girmama shi (sake gabatarwa ga Nobel, Pulitzer Prize, da wasu kyaututtuka masu daraja) ya samar da wani littafi mai ban mamaki - The Dying Animal. A shekara ta 2007, Isabel Coixet ya karɓa, kuma Nicholas Meyer ya karbi aikin wallafe-wallafe. Isabel mai kyau ("Paris, je t'aime", "Rayuwa ba tare da ni ba", "Asirin Rayuwa na Maganar") ya sanya alamar ba da kadan ba inda marubucin asalin asalin ya ɗauka. Amma wannan, watakila, wani al'amari ne na dandano da kuma kusurwa na zane-zane.

Dan takarar Ben Kingley da Dennis Hopper da Patricia Clarkson da kuma Paz Vega sun amince da babban mataki, amma a kan Paz ya bayyana Penelope Cruz. Ba a bayyana bayanin ba, kuma 'yan Intanet sun fara mamaki: me ya sa hakan zai kasance? Fassara mai ɗorewa kamar sauti: "Anyi wannan ne don kiyaye daidaito na shekarun da suka dace da haruffa da kuma masu aiki." Kamar, Kingsley ya tsufa fiye da Cruz duk tsawon shekaru talatin ... Amma game da wannan - a kasa.

Da zarar wani mutumin da ya fara girma ya zabi: ya canza mummunan abu, amma rayuwar iyali, zuwa gagarumar baƙin ciki, kuma, daidai da haka, maras iyali. Ta haka ne, wasan kwaikwayo na ciki ya fara: gwagwarmaya tsakanin hedonism da hankali a cikin wani mutum. Wannan gwagwarmaya a zukatan babban halayen ya wuce tare da sauye-sauye na nasara don lokaci, har zuwa lokacin. Lokaci ya zo / a wani wuri a cikin yanki "bayan hamsin": to, hedonism a hankali (kamar yadda ya faru) ya girma cikin rashin tsoro, ƙwarewa da rashin iyawa don magance matsaloli.

Me ya sa wannan ya faru, bayan haka, idan kayi la'akari da hankali, rayuwa ta kasance nasara, kuma duk abin da ya fito kusan kamar yadda kuke son shi ya kasance? Kusan duk komai banda daya: farfesa yana da tsufa, wanda ba shi da karfin zuciya kuma ba shi da komai. Kuma wannan tsari na halitta, yana jin tsoron gaske. Bugu da ƙari, wasan kwaikwayon na gargajiya na yau da kullum ya haɗu ba tare da ƙananan bayanan wasan kwaikwayon na al'ada ba: ƙwararraki ko "... ya dace da mahaifinka". Gaba ɗaya, shi farfesa ne na wallafe-wallafe, ita ce tsohon ɗalibansa. Da farko suna da jima'i, sai kauna, to, rikicin da rashin fahimta. Tsakanin su - babbar ilimi a cikin duka, shekaru talatin masu banbanci, abokantaka na "lafiya" da aboki don magana "game da shi." Hakika, ba za su yi nasara ba ...

Ma'anar, bisa ma'ana, ba ta da muhimmanci. Amma dai dai a cikin wannan yanayin ya yi kama da sabo ne - a cikin wannan ƙimar, babu shakka, Penelope Cruz (ta dauki nauyin jiki) da kuma Ben Kingsley tare da tunaninsa. Lokaci mafi kyau na fim: mutuwar aboki da shawarar da ba'a buƙatar bayyanawa ba, amma suna a fili kuma ba tare da wata hanya ba.

Saboda haka: yawancin tunani, mai yawa tsirara Penelope Cruz, tunani mai yawa da kuma karshe. Babbar matashi, mai tunani da fina-finai ga wadanda suke da wani abu da za su yi tunani da jin dadi.


Natalia Rudenko